4.90 ★
Sherman Cottage
House·8 guests·3 bedrooms·2 bathrooms
You will be close to everything when you stay at this cottage right downtown in Old Harbor on Dodge St with direct beach access. Now rented by Herdman Hospitality, this 3-bedroom (king, 2 queens, pull-out), 2 full bathroom cottage, fully equipped with modern amenities like a full kitchen, washer/dry...
Amenities
Free WiFi
Kitchen
Air conditioning
Washing Machine
Pets allowed
Suitable for children
Available days
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
Reviews
4.90 (4)·Zachary Novick·September 2026
Great place for a family vacation!
·Beth Hunt·September 2026
We stayed with friends and had a great time. The property is small, but perfectly located within walking distance to everything and had everything we needed. The island is just so beautiful and we had such a fun time reconnecting with our friends. The only weird thing was the small homeless encampment in the parking lot. People hung out and some lived there and were friendly, but it was a little unsettling.
·Allison Straub·September 2026
Great location and very comfortable beds!
·Ian Wright·September 2026
Clean and comfortable. AC, TVs and modern kitchen appliances all good. Great location - handy base for exploring the island.
Good to know
House Rules
Check-in: 3 pm
Check-out: 10 am
Pets: allowed
Smoking inside: not allowed
Cancellation policy
100% refund up to 60 days before arrival
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌